The Egg Bill is a compromise that responds to the concerns about animals with requirements that the egg producers can accept. In today's hyperpolarized world, that's not just a victory. It's an example of the way things should work.
"The congressional legislation that has resulted from this unusual alliance shows a good balance between real-world egg-production practices and the idealistic goal of free-range chicken farming.... Congress, though, has a clear mandate to act from the farmers who know best how they want their eggs done."
"This bill, (H.R. 3798), deserves swift enactment. And the process by which it even got this far ought to be a model for politically warring factions everywhere."
"It's well past time to create a national standard that promotes more humane conditions everywhere. "
"The legislation exemplifies how traditional adversaries can put aside their distrust and work together for each side's mutual benefit. As lead sponsor, Schrader deserves credit for his role on H.R. 3798 (the egg bill). Congress should pass it. Soon."
"A federal law is the only way to mandate uniform standards, and this smart and focused measure is supported by the United Egg Producers, which represents 88% of the nation's egg farmers. As legislation goes, it's a good egg."
"It's no sure thing that Congress will approve the national standard; But the agreement on laying hens is a fair compromise."
"We know that animals feel discomfort and pain. We know that bad conditions can cause them great distress. Because the animals are in our power and helpless, we must avoid cruelty at all costs. Congress should pass the bill."
"This is an important measure, especially in Pennsylvania, which is the third-largest egg producer in the country....This is not just about providing better conditions for chickens, although that is important. The changes also give consumers better information about the eggs they buy. Wording will specify how the animals that laid their eggs are kept—from caged hens to those that are free to roam."
"Allowing hens a little room to spread their wings and places to perch, nest, and scratch seems pretty reasonable....The accord between the HSUS and the egg producers is something to crow about."
"Federal regulation of eggs and other agricultural products is not new. Most people in the egg industry want this updated legislation because it sets a uniform playing field for everyone instead of having states develop their own standards. Furthermore, evidence suggests that hens' egg production increases at farms that have installed the new cages."
"Compromise offered the best possible outcome. Federal rules would benefit all 280 million hens rather than just 6 million Washington cluckers. The egg industry would get a nationwide standard to live by rather than a hodgepodge of state laws, and voters won't have to make the call about how best to balance animal welfare and commerce. Would that more groups were able to settle their differences in such a way, without forcing the electorate into all-or-nothing scenarios that rarely come without major complications."